This is an incredibly thought-provoking post. I’ve never before heard about this incident and will definitely give it some thought. In my 5 years of research on the battle, I’ve not once come across a reference to this particular incident so I am skeptical that it explains the massacre. That said, I would like to know if there are other editorials referencing the behavior of USCTs that might collectively help to frame the massacre at the Crater. The rumor mill can easily be located within the broader historic framework that I am working to better understand.

Thanks again and look for a response on my blog in the next few days.